Why Crimea holds key to peace in Russia-Ukraine war

Crimea is at the heart of Europe’s deadliest war in decades. As both Russia and Ukraine refuse to budge, the question of Crimea’s future looms large and divisive.

The peninsula, seized by Russian forces in 2014 without a shot being fired, is now a symbol of national pride in Russia and a matter of sovereignty and survival for Ukraine.

“There is nothing to talk about. It is our land, the land of the Ukrainian people,” Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy declared firmly this week, rejecting any deal that would allow Russia to keep Crimea.

However, US President Donald Trump accused Zelenskyy of prolonging the war by refusing to consider territorial concessions.

“If he wants Crimea, why didn’t they fight for it eleven years ago when it was handed over to Russia without a shot being fired?” Trump asked on social media, calling Zelenskyy’s stance “very harmful” to peace negotiations.

Russia, for its part, insists that Crimea — annexed in 2014 following a controversial referendum — is non-negotiable. “Crimea is a sacred place,” President Vladimir Putin has said, framing the region as a symbol of Russian pride and history.

A Legacy of Blood and Borders

Crimea’s value is more than symbolic. It has long been a geopolitical prize — first annexed by the Russian Empire in the 18th century, then transferred to Ukraine in 1954 by Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev. After the fall of the Soviet Union, it remained Ukrainian territory, though Russia never relinquished its grip.

That tenuous balance collapsed in 2014 when Russian troops moved in following the ousting of Ukraine’s pro-Moscow president. Moscow quickly held a referendum — rejected by the West — and claimed Crimea as its own. The world is divided once again, not along borders, but by beliefs.

“Crimea is ours!” became a rallying cry across Russia. In the West, the move was widely condemned as a breach of international law, with only a handful of nations — such as North Korea and Sudan — recognising the annexation.

Strategic Stakes in a Shifting War

Crimea’s location makes it invaluable to both sides. The peninsula houses Russia’s Black Sea Fleet and acts as a springboard for missile strikes and logistical support across southern Ukraine. It also connects the mainland via the Kerch Bridge — a frequent target of Ukrainian sabotage missions.

“Russia won’t be able to steal the peninsula,” Zelenskyy has vowed, as Ukraine steps up its campaign of drone attacks and strikes deep into Russian-held territory.

U.S. officials, including Vice President JD Vance, have floated a possible peace plan reportedly calling for a freeze on current territorial lines. But it’s unclear whether that would require Kyiv to effectively surrender Crimea.

“It’s time for them to either say ‘yes’ or for the United States to walk away from this process,” Vance said during a recent visit to India, describing the plan as “a very fair proposal.”

More Than Just Land

Covering 27,000 square kilometers — slightly smaller than Belgium — Crimea was once a cornerstone of Ukraine’s economy. Before its annexation, it contributed roughly 3% to national GDP and drew millions of tourists each year.

Its ports were key to Ukraine’s grain exports — until Russia’s 2022 invasion and blockade sent shockwaves through global food markets. The fallout helped tank the Black Sea Grain Initiative and disrupted trade routes across the region.

Today, Crimea is both a military asset and a global economic pressure point.

A Fault Line with No Clear Future

As the war drags on and battlefield lines harden, Putin has added Crimea’s recognition to his list of demands for peace — alongside Ukraine abandoning NATO ambitions and surrendering four additional territories.

Zelenskyy has flatly rejected the proposal, instead doubling down on retaking Crimea and restoring all of Ukraine’s 1991 borders. “We are absolutely sure that our partners, in particular the USA, will act in line with its strong decisions,” he said, referencing longstanding US opposition to the annexation.

For now, Russia controls about 20 per cent of Ukraine’s territory. Crimea remains both a crown jewel and a potential powder keg.

(With inputs from Associated Press, Reuters)

Tune In